There’s some intriguing drama brewing in the world of 90-Day Fiancé, as it seems Josh Weinstein may be pursuing a new romance.
Speculation is mounting that Josh, a 43-year-old modeling CEO, might have set his sights on none other than Jen Potis, the older
sister of Elizabeth “Libby” Potis. A recent video shared by the fan account 90Day Fiancé Update showed the two getting cozy, leading
fans to wonder if this could be the beginning of a new couple within the franchise.
The fan account’s post fueled excitement by suggesting that Jen has been Josh’s mystery girlfriend for quite some time, especially given that he tagged her in an Instagram post. Moreover, fans noted that Josh has established ties to the Potis family, as Libby’s mother runs a casting agency. The combination of familiarity and appearances together has fans buzzing about the potential of this new romance.
While neither Jen Potis nor Josh Weinstein has publicly addressed these swirling rumors, this isn’t the first time the two have been spotted together. They were previously seen hanging out in February 2023, during a time when Josh was still romantically involved with Natalie Morva, his longtime love interest from the show. At that time, Josh’s ex-wife Candace Michler stepped in to quash speculation, labeling Jen and Josh as “just friends” and confirming that his relationship with Natalie was still ongoing.
Josh and Natalie’s relationship has had its share of ups and downs; the couple first appeared on the 90 Day: The Single Life in its second season in 2022, and they continued their roller coaster ride through seasons three and four. Most recently, they were featured on the spinoff 90 Day: The Last Resort, which premiered in December 2024. This season found them as the only unmarried couple at a retreat, given one last chance to decide their future together.
Their storyline took an emotional turn when Josh and Natalie reconnected after a traumatic car accident involving Josh’s son. However, tension soon flared when Natalie confronted castmate Sophie Sierra after discovering that Josh had been messaging her on social media. This type of tumult has been characteristic of Josh and Natalie’s relationship, leading fans to question the strength of their connection.
On February 25th, Josh confirmed on the Sarah Fraser Show podcast that he and Natalie had officially parted ways after filming, stating, “At the moment, I would say we are friends.” He acknowledged that Natalie’s dependency on him had strung their relationship along, explaining that he often felt like her only support system amid her personal struggles. This revelation added layers to their dynamic, as it appeared that concern for her well-being may have kept them tied together longer than they should have been.
Despite their split, Josh expressed that he still cares for Natalie deeply. He described the complexities of their relationship, revealing that he held onto it partly because he felt a responsibility to look out for her. This emotional pull raises questions about how easily he can transition into a new relationship with Jen, especially amidst the realities and pressures of being in the spotlight.
With Josh and Jen now spotted together, fans are left wondering if he has truly moved on from Natalie and is ready to explore this potential new romance. The intertwining lives of these 90-Day Fiancé stars continue to captivate audiences, keeping viewers eager for more updates on the developments of their relationships. As the drama unfolds, fans will be watching closely to see if this potential pairing between Josh and Jen blossoms or if it fizzles out before it truly begins.
