Billy talked with Dumas.

The March 25 episode of The Young and the Restless was all about Aristotle Dumas, the only man who, it would seem, can actually give Victor Newman a run for his money. (Though Victor always wins in the end, of course.) Dumas reached out to Billy, seemingly looking to team up against Victor, while Victor told Lily how Dumas was connected to Damian and thus couldn’t be trusted.

But who is this mystery man? He can’t be a total stranger, can he? He’s got to be somebody from the past. After all, does anything happen in Genoa City if it’s not about Victor? Victor thinks now.

Already Here

Maybe we’ve already met Mr. Dumas, but we don’t know it. Damian (Jermaine Rivers) and Holden (Nate Owens) have both pretended to be somebody else in the few short weeks they’ve been around. So why not add another identity to either — or both; maybe that’s how they managed to get so much done. They’re two men pretending to be one — of their long list of aliases.

MORE: Find out what happens next on Y&R.

Grudge Match

Jack (Peter Bergman) pulled the wool over Victor’s (Eric Braeden) eyes before when he was the mystery buyer who snatched up the companies Victor thought he’d stolen from Jabot. What if he’s been doing it for years? Or what if this is Diane’s ultimate secret? She’s been the power broker all along!

READ MORE: See a peek at what happens next on Y&R.

Lady of the Day

Just because Aristotle Dumas sounds like a man’s name doesn’t necessarily mean that’s who the ultimate puppet master is. (Sure, Billy [Jason Thomspon] spoke to the dude on the phone, but as Damian and Holden have proven, those kinds of switches are easy.)

What if it’s a woman? One particular woman, as a matter of fact? What if it’s Lori Brooks (Jamie Lynn Bauer), the one woman who has outsmarted Victor over and over and over again? And she’s back for another round.